Freezing is better than acid for common warts, but the same for plantar warts

Goodfellow Gems Logo

Goodfellow Gems

Freezing is better than acid for common warts but the same for plantar warts

A recent Alberta Tools for Practice1review noted the following:

Quality primary care evidence finds warts resolve with cryotherapy (39% of participants) versus salicylic acid (SA) (24%) more than no treatment (16%) at 13 weeks.  

For plantar warts: Cryotherapy 30%, SA 33%, no treatment 23% (none statistically significant).2 Cryotherapy has more pain and blistering (up to ~80%), but greater patient satisfaction (~70%). Evidence for duct tape is limited and inconsistent.

For plantar warts, consider paring to overlying skin (to confirm it is a wart and to see the “salt and pepper” capillaries, or a corn which disappears) and applying topical SA (40% strength). This is much less painful that freezing and appears to be just as effective. If that fails then cryotherapy is reasonable. 

A suggestion is to keep a supply of salicylic acid in the clinic and give small lots to patients to save on prescription costs.

References:

  1. Alberta tools for Practice # 173
  2. Bruggink SC, Gussekloo J, Berger MY, et al. CMAJ. 2010; 182:1624-30. Click here

    Gems are chosen by the Goodfellow director Dr. Bruce Arroll to be either practice changing or practice maintaining. The information is educational and not clinical advice.

     
    This Gem is supported by: